Madonna Talking to Macy's

Oh, the wild joys of being a weird celebrity designer. 'Tis true that life is short and rarely private. So we appreciate fashions that are even shorter and more exposing. My take on any future Madonna Wraps, scant and senseless as they might be, is that they would be just another pimple on the ever-evolving face of worldly fashion.

Gene Hoffman, President/CEO, Corporate Strategies International

To me, the bigger story isn't that yet another celebrity is riding fame to the beach through fashion. I'm looking at the deals that Iconix is making (Madonna) and not making (Playboy falling through) as a barometer for the retailer-as-licensee movement that Iconix increasingly owns in soft lines. Playboy, with its retail stores, convoluted licensing agreements and Hef hanging on with his long teeth, is Byzantine by comparison (though in the past, all of that would have been called an "opportunity").

To me, this signals that celebrity licensing is still one of the more straightforward and bankable arrangements, particularly for a global icon such as Madonna and a low overhead pure marketing company like Iconix.

Carol Spieckerman, President, newmarketbuilders

Madonna had vast influence on fashion and popular culture in the '80s...but the question is how her iconic status would translate into a design point of view. The brand position should be "contemporary" but the age demographic is frankly not going to be as young as Macy's might prefer. It's certainly an idea worth exploring; many of Macy's marketing initiatives and exclusive brands are celebrity-focused, and a "Madonna Collection" would fit right in.

Richard Seesel, Principal, Retailing In Focus LLC

I'm reserving judgment until I see the line. Madonna dresses pretty weird on stage and I'm wondering if your average Macy's customer can appreciate Madonna's style. I'm assuming the pointy brassiere will not make it into the collection.

Doron Levy, President, TheMortgageMachine.ca

Whenever the business is soft, it turns into a market share, zero sum game. A sure sign of this is a spate of exclusive celebrity lines. Would a Madonna line mean anything? Who knows? In the end it depends, as always, on the product. This means the designers selected, the piece goods, the needle, and the value proposition. Beyond that, it is simply marketing and another royalty check for the Material Girl.

Bill Emerson, President, Emerson Advisors

Madonna is a good businesswoman. I'm betting she'll do well by this deal. As to Macy's? I'm frankly a lot less bullish. A brand blindly seeking a demographic is a brand in trouble.

Ryan Mathews, Founder, ceo, Black Monk Consulting

Ewww. Does ANYONE want to look like Madonna?

Cathy Hotka, Principal, Cathy Hotka & Associates

Her line at H&M was hugely successful and that apparel was much more conservative than anything Gwen Stefani's LAMB Line or Beyonce's line offers.

Madonna is still relevant--whether you love her or hate her. She is still photographed in fashion magazines around the globe. Her impact is huge. And again, whether you're a fan or not, she is a stellar business woman. This is not someone who parades around in her underwear while not on stage and I doubt that she'll be offering stage outfits to the masses. Her line will probably be in line with what was offered at H&M in 2007 and heck, I wore those shirts and blazers to work!

If Gwen Stefani was successful (and she's a Madonna follower) than no doubt Madonna will be successful. Pun intended!

'SALSGPA1972'

How many 50 year old Material Girls shop at Macy's anymore? How many younger women aspire to dress like a 50 year old Material Girl? Lots of people of all ages enjoy her fabulous music and performing talents but Madonna the fashion icon is sooo 1980s. If she were still living life as a British country noblewoman perhaps she could work some of that style into an unexpectedly serious fashion line--but that part of her life is also over, so 2000s and so Mrs. Guy Ritchie. But score one more "scoop" and another free media mention for Macy's indefatigable PR department.

'Liatt'

Someone needs to get to her and tell her not to do it! Whoever that person is, they need to be strong enough to show her the receding customer base for department stores, the dying revenues, the qualitative research that shows D-stores are a dinosaur about to be extinct. That person needs to be able to clearly over-rule and crush Madonna's entourage with clarity and good marketing sense. That person must change her mind about this quickly before it's too late.

I volunteer me for the duty!

Lee Peterson, EVP Creative Services, WD Partners

Madonna is a celebrity and an entertainer. But, most of all she is an entrepreneur. She is perhaps the most successful business person to come out of the performance industry. Great care should be taken in predicting the failure of this proposed business.

But, failure may be on the label. "Material Girl" and "Truth or Dare" are names of an era past. There is no longer a great connection to those who are part of that generation. Do they really want to be a "Material Girl"?

But, the other side of the argument is that Madonna is an icon for 40+ or 50+ year old women. She continues to connect. That connection is considerably more mature (and more elegant) than it was 20 years ago.

Madonna, now hear this!!! Forget "Material Girl." Forget "Truth or Dare." Put your own name on the line and you will communicate all that is necessary to your targets and this venture will be hugely successful.

Gene Detroyer, Entrepreneur, Advisor, Consultant, Professor, Independent

Reading the list of celeb designers--can any list featuring BOTH the Olsen twins and Lindsay Lohan be anything positive? I think Madonna has too much class and dignity for this to work...wait, did I just write that??? Anyway, I've never understood the appeal of wanting to look like someone else, so I'll pass on what prospects this has, but I'm surprised we haven't yet seen a comment along the lines of "there goes Macy's again, latching onto yesterday's news."

'notcom'

I wish I could be positive about Macy's initiative on this but frankly the alliance could be subtitled "When dying brands collide."

I'd be fascinated to see any research that was done. It would be interesting to see the brand attributes that Madonna represents for women of all ages but most particularly for women in the 18-34 age range.

That said, I have to agree with those panelists who view this as an union better executed in the 1980's.

Doug Stephens, President, Retail Prophet

Well, if this is a business decision, what were they thinking? Fun to discuss, but hard to see who the target shopper might be. Unless she has another totally unexpected surprise for an unsuspecting public!

Anne Bieler, Sr. Associate, Packaging and Technology Integrated Solutions

Madonna is smart, knows style, and fashion, and sex. A bankable combination if there ever was one. This is one of the best opportunities that Macy's has had in a long time and one that it would be foolish to bet against.

Phil Rubin, CEO, rDialogue

Madonna is past 50 years old. So what age group will she be designing for?

She does have her glorious past, but can it translate to today's ultra fickle Twitter environment?

This is a gamble that may or may not pay out for Macy's.

'weo'