Bill Hanifin

CEO, Hanifin Loyalty LLC

Bill Hanifin brings over 25 years experience encompassing customer centric marketing, payment systems, and corporate banking to benefit the clients he serves. Bill has concentrated on developing and implementing Customer Strategies designed to address a range of business objectives from account acquisition and sales performance to improved customer retention and increased share of wallet and brand preference.

Bill has worked with companies in the airline, banking, hotel, retail, telecom, and business services sectors providing a range of services including Strategic Marketing Plans, Project Management, Financial Measurement, and Operational Solutions. A partial Client list includes American Express, BBVA Bancomer, Banco BHD, FirstCaribbean Int’l Bank, Grupo Posadas (largest hotel chain in Mexico), JM Associates Federal Credit Union, LaQuinta Inns, Scotiabank, Visa, and

Bill is a Founding Member of the Customer Strategy Network, a global network of independent relationship and loyalty marketing practitioners. He authors Loyalty Truth, a blog covering all aspects of Customer Centric marketing, and serves as North American Contributing Editor for The Wise Marketer, a global publication covering the loyalty marketing industry.

Bill is an accomplished speaker and trainer and is a requested presenter at industry trade conferences sponsored by Airline Information, SourceMedia, the Direct Marketing Association, Visa, Loyalty 360, and the Institute for International Research. He has led public and privately organized workshops in the U.S., Canada, Latin America, EU, and Asia Pacific regions.

Bill is a prolific writer on the subjects of Millennial, Loyalty, and Relationship marketing. In addition to his blog Loyalty Truth, his articles and quotes have been published in American Banker, Colloquy, Cards & Payments, Card Technology,, DM News, Fox, Smart Money, and

  • Posted on: 08/16/2017

    Will more promos fix Dick’s Sporting Goods pricing challenge?

    Dick's could be the poster child for testing whether a focus on customer experience can outweigh other factors in maintaining market share. It is probably inevitable that the chain will have to soften its pricing and accept a future life with slightly lower margin. That said, if it thinks that price and promotion alone will protect market share and the core business over the long term, think again.Taking on the fight with, for instance, Amazon, seems to be a losing battle. Dick's should make some adjustments in its pricing formulas, but otherwise consider the many opportunities to leverage its physical store chain to attract and maintain customers.I've seen where Saks and other are opening gyms in their stores. I'm not sold on this as the brand does not fit with the activity. Dick's however, has the opportunity to bring people into the store to do what they want to do with the clothes, shoes, and equipment they purchase. It seems a perfect fit.
  • Posted on: 08/16/2017

    What bad habits do retail solution providers need to break?

    Fully agree with Dave Bruno below. My description is that we need to deliver first, build trust and only then seek to "ladder up" in the organization to sell more product or services. All too often, a first sale is made and more attention is given to incremental business than delivering on the reality of the day. Stay focused, be grateful for what you have, and build trust with your client. Good things will happen down the road.
  • Posted on: 06/30/2017

    Does Blue Apron’s ‘meh’ IPO spell trouble for meal kit services?

    A quick analysis of the financials disclosed in the Blue Apron circular shows amazing growth between 2014 - 2015, with growth in 2016, but at a reduced rate. Investors should have demanded to see how the growth pattern continues through the end of 2017 in order to draw conclusions about retention rates.I've seen criticism of the marketing spend at Blue Apron, but as a percent of revenues, the numbers have remained consistent in the 18% range. Overall, Opex is decreasing as a % of revenues over the 2014 - 2016 period. At least the company is controlling overall expense levels as sales grow.This is a company which might have been better advised to stay out of public markets. The model is too easy to duplicate for the company to sustain market value over a longer period of time. A better strategy would have been to achieve profitability and become an acquisition target on a smaller scale.
  • Posted on: 06/28/2017

    Can fitness classes wake up retail store traffic?

    Incorporating fitness and meditation classes in a retail setting only makes sense when both directly reinforce the core brand promise. For example, Lululemon offers yoga and other fitness related events in its retail stores. This is a good fit and, from what I know, the response from local communities where this takes place has been positive.Outside of this very narrow channel of opportunity, I don't see the concept working. I never associated "sweat" with the Saks brand and the number of alternatives for most Saks shoppers inclined towards fitness are too many to expect much participation, whether a loyal Saks shopper or not.
  • Posted on: 06/27/2017

    What happens when you put a c-store on wheels?

    We are living in a time when technologists are exploring every possibility for solutions that will save us time or make our lives easier. I think it's important to remember that just because a new tech solution is introduced, in this case Moby Mart, it does not mean there was a problem to solve in the first place.If we continue to seek out retail solutions that allow us to get everything at our beck and call while not moving far from our desks, we risk becoming a bit more sedentary and robot-like each day. The convenience store business itself is undergoing massive evolution right now, and the changes taking place as stores transform into meeting places that offer quality foods should be enough to engage consumers.Why we need to have an app-controlled vending machine roll up to our door is a mystery to me. I still prefer, as do many humans, a trip down the hall or across the street to get some fresh air, talk with a colleague and grab a hot or cold beverage.
  • Posted on: 06/22/2017

    Is Starbucks passing the buck to baristas on customer service?

    A solid approach to improving any process is to identify the root cause issues that are creating inefficiencies that lead to poor customer satisfaction. It seems that Starbucks could have polled the barista community as to their opinions on the root causes and then addressed these issues with solutions in hand as part of the North Star meetings. Maybe Starbucks did take this approach, but it does not seem apparent in the articles here.
  • Posted on: 06/21/2017

    Why did McDonald’s end its Olympic sponsorship?

    The Olympics are problematic for many companies considering sponsorship for several of the reasons you have well outlined. Time zone differences, access to results, athlete tracking via social media and geo-political concerns are all valid reasons that brands might struggle with Olympic sponsorship.Probably the biggest challenge for McDonald's in particular is the brand mismatch. Watching a high-level athlete promote burgers and fries is not an easy message to swallow (pun intended).An equally interesting question is why the other brands mentioned (AT&T, Citi, Hilton) opted out. Each of these has a global footprint and there are no brand compatibility issues. Possibly geo-political concerns as well as continual allegations raised against IOC's handling of site selection and budget are impacting these relationships.
  • Posted on: 06/19/2017

    Did Amazon just patent tech that could end showrooming in its stores?

    Readers should not jump to the conclusion that Amazon will use this patented technology to prevent customers from searching online while in their stores. Showrooming was shown to be a positive for the customer shopping experience a few years ago and I think Amazon is too smart to make the blunder of preventing the behavior in its stores today. The expectation should be that Amazon will analyze the collected data to optimize its product merchandising and pricing strategies.As the lead article states, "A five percent discount would be enough to convince 60 percent of shoppers to buy online instead of from a store." Amazon would only have to make a small adjustment in pricing to stop the bleeding to other sources.One other thought: Considering that many of the showrooming shoppers in brick-and-mortar retailers were probably migrating away to Amazon to get that 5 percent discount, I wonder how much sales loss really concerns Amazon.
  • Posted on: 06/19/2017

    Will the Bonobos acquisition give Walmart a fashion edge?

    I agree with the others who have commented so far that the brands are not complementary. Bonobos are high quality products that are sold with a high level of custom care. They are also pricey. Therefore the advantage Walmart seeks to create through this acquisition is not immediately clear.As stated in the lead article, "the main benefit of adding niche brands such as Bonobos is to gain a better reach and understanding of younger, urban and more upscale consumers." If that means the play is for customer data and segment intelligence, $310 million is an expensive price tag for customer data.If Bonobos will become part of the Jet group and therefore not associated directly with the Walmart brand in the marketplace, then Walmart would appear to be continuing on its path to aggregate fashion brands into a separate portfolio. Creating a wholly separate business that just happens to be under the Walmart umbrella makes the most sense.
  • Posted on: 06/16/2017

    What happens now that Amazon is acquiring Whole Foods?

    Two things come to mind regarding the deal announced today between Amazon and Whole Foods:1. Most stories in the press that I have read are sharing the view that "Whole Foods Market stores and its headquarters operation won’t look much different after the sale." I would bet on the veracity of that statement for about 12 - 18 months, but after that, the leadership, structure and overall operational persona of Whole Foods will be drastically different from what we see today.2. There are multiple opportunities to "win" for Amazon and Whole Foods.
    • For Whole Foods, they may add efficiency to their supply chain to bring down the prices of healthy food products and shed the image of "whole paycheck." Just read the funny tweets about the sale today and you'll see how strongly painted the brand is with that imagery.
    • For Whole Foods, they may be the first to democratize healthy eating. While many consumers are interested in eating better and taking care of their health, it is not affordable for most. This model may finally change.
    • For Amazon, instead of experimenting with Kiosks and pop-up stores, they will have an instant brick and mortar footprint and can optimize the merchandise offered. Rather than simply turning WF into an Amazon outlet, the better idea is to selectively seed WF with items that will drive foot traffic and give consumers a brand new reason to make shopping at WF a regular stop.
    • For Amazon, they are entering the grocery market at a time when leading competitors are under pressure from new market entrants. Kroger is feeling that pressure from Lidl's planned market entry and Walmart is always pushing the full priced grocers. Innovation in delivery and the ability to make shopping about WF about much more than grocery will add a new dimension to the competitive marketplace.
  • Posted on: 05/31/2017

    Will Amazon’s use of data transform how retailers operate stores?

    Amazon's physical book stores can offer another "Trojan Horse" towards their larger entry into the brick and mortar retail space. I believe Amazon will turn browsing and purchasing books into an experience that consumers will enjoy to pass some time. In the process, Amazon can seed the stores with coffee, wifi and highlight rotating displays on items they wish to feature. The stores can be smallish, while becoming a place of discovery, fun, and encounter for shoppers.
  • Posted on: 05/12/2017

    What makes consumers so loyal to Publix, Wegmans, Trader Joe’s and H-E-B?

    The beauty of the question posed here for discussion is that it highlights the opportunity for each brand to carve out its own niche. While each of the grocers might have all of the attributes on their "list," they clearly each prioritize and weight efforts to align with their own brand promise.If you contrast the shopping experience and types of grocery customers attracted by Costco, Walmart, Trader Joe's and Publix, you would end up with different elements from the list at the top. The answer then, as my UK friends like to say, is "horses for courses."
  • Posted on: 05/12/2017

    Do customer reviews suffer from a herd mentality?

    The tribe of digitally connected consumers regularly uses reviews as part of their decision-making process for purchase. I hazard the guess that most members of this tribe consume reviews with a "buyer beware" attitude.I endorse light curation of reviews by retailers in order to monitor extreme opinions that are not helpful to any consumer, or those that are identified as having been planted with a purpose.Beyond that, let reviews stand as they are. The online experience has matured to the point where consumers are capable of exercising discernment in their interpretation of the message.
  • Posted on: 05/10/2017

    Should more brands offer rewards linked to store purchases?

    This is a contentious discussion due to one fact -- this is a difficult challenge to solve. As I mentioned in a reply to Gene, I am hesitant to dismiss too readily the range of attempts to connect end-consumer with manufacturer, at least until a clear long term solution is in the market.Full integration of a grocery loyalty program to CPG's is probably the best path, but there are complex technical and business issues to solve. As you know, some grocers resist the loyalty play, so the vehicle that could connect parties is not available.We'll all keep working on this challenge and the one who solves it with technical ease and in a way to deliver a great customer experience for the customer will be a big winner.
  • Posted on: 05/10/2017

    Should more brands offer rewards linked to store purchases?

    Gene, while I understand the sentiment, I don't dismiss the range of attempts to connect end-consumer with manufacturer. The reason there is not a universal, elegant solution is that it is an extremely difficult nut to crack. Code-on-pack was the limit of most people's thinking and receipt capture and validation is a build on the previous generation. Full integration of a grocery loyalty program to CPGs is possible, but there are complex technical and business issues to solve. As you know, some grocers resist the loyalty play, so the vehicle that could connect parties is not available. We'll all keep working on this challenge and the one who solves it with technical ease and in a way to deliver a great customer experience for the customer will be a big winner.

Contact Bill

  • Apply to be a BrainTrust Panelist

  • Please briefly describe your qualifications — specifically, your expertise and experience in the retail industry.